Difference between revisions of "Affirmative-negative question"

m (Text replacement - "{{HSK|HSK2}}" to "{{HSK|HSK2}}{{2021-HSK|HSK2}}")
 
(41 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 18: Line 18:
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
  
* <em>是 不 是</em> ? <span class="pinyin"><em>Shì shì</em>?</span> <span class="trans">Is it (or not)?</span>
+
* <em>是 不 是</em> ? <span class="pinyin"><em>Shì bu shì</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is it (or not)?</span>
* 他们 <em>来 不 来</em> ? <span class="pinyin">Tāmen <em>lái lái</em>?</span> <span class="trans">Are they going to come or not?</span>
+
* 他们 <em>来 不 来</em> ? <span class="pinyin">Tāmen <em>lái bu lái</em>?</span><span class="trans">Are they going to come or not?</span>
* 你 <em>想 不 想</em> 我 ? <span class="pinyin">Nǐ <em>xiǎng xiǎng</em> wǒ?</span> <span class="trans">Do you or do you not miss me?</span>
+
* 你 <em>想 不 想</em> 我 ? <span class="pinyin">Nǐ <em>xiǎng bu xiǎng</em> wǒ?</span><span class="trans">Do you or do you not miss me?</span>
* 我们 要 去 酒吧, 你 <em>去 不 去</em> ? <span class="pinyin">Wǒmen yào qù jiǔbā, nǐ <em> qù qù </em>?</span> <span class="trans">We are going to the bar.Do you want to go?</span>
+
* 我们 要 去 酒吧, 你 <em>去 不 去</em>?<span class="pinyin">Wǒmen yào qù jiǔbā, nǐ <em> qù bu qù</em>?</span><span class="trans">We are going to the bar. Do you want to go? </span>
* 我 去 买 咖啡 ,你 <em>要 不 要</em> ? <span class="pinyin">Wǒ qù mǎi kāfēi, <em>yào yào</em>?</span> <span class="trans">I‘m going to buy coffee.Do you want some?</span>
+
* 我 去 买 咖啡 ,你 <em>要 不 要</em> ? <span class="pinyin">Wǒ qù mǎi kāfēi, <em>yào bu yào</em>?</span><span class="trans">I'm going to buy coffee. Do you want some?</span>
 
 
  
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 45: Line 44:
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
  
* 你 <em> 回 不 回 </em> 家? <span class="pinyin">Nǐ <em> huí huí </em> jiā?</span> <span class="trans">Are you coming back home or not?</span>
+
* 你 <em> 回 不 回</em> 家? <span class="pinyin">Nǐ <em> huí bu huí</em>jiā?</span><span class="trans">Are you coming back home or not?</span>
* 她 <em> 吃 不 吃</em> 鱼? <span class="pinyin">Tā<em>chī chī</em> yú?</span> <span class="trans">Does she eat fish?</span>
+
* 她 <em> 吃 不 吃</em> 鱼? <span class="pinyin">Tā<em> chī bu chī</em> yú?</span><span class="trans">Does she eat fish?</span>
* 你们 <em>要 不 要</em> 米饭? <span class="pinyin">Nǐmen <em>yào yào</em> mǐfàn?</span> <span class="trans">Do you want rice?</span>
+
* 你们 <em>要 不 要</em> 米饭? <span class="pinyin">Nǐmen <em>yào bu yào</em> mǐfàn?</span><span class="trans">Do you want rice?</span>
* 你爸爸 <em>喝 不 喝</em> 酒? <span class="pinyin">Nǐ bàba ​<em>hē hē</em> jiǔ?</span> <span class="trans">Does your dad drink alcohol or not?</span>
+
* 你爸爸 <em>喝 不 喝</em> 酒? <span class="pinyin">Nǐ bàba ​<em>hē bu hē</em>jiǔ?</span><span class="trans">Does your dad drink alcohol or not?</span>
* 今天 老板 <em>来 不 来</em> 办公室?<span class="pinyin">Jīntiān lǎobǎn <em>lái lái</em> bàngōngshì?</span> <span class="trans">Is the boss coming to the office today?</span>
+
* 今天 老板 <em>来 不 来</em> 办公室?<span class="pinyin">Jīntiān lǎobǎn <em>lái bu lái</em> bàngōngshì?</span><span class="trans">Is the boss coming to the office today?</span>
  
  
Line 70: Line 69:
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
  
* <em>好 不 好</em> ?<span class="pinyin"><em>Hǎo hǎo</em>?</span> <span class="trans">Is it good? (or "good or not good?")</span>
+
* <em>好 不 好</em> ?<span class="expl">Literally, "good or not good?"</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Hǎo bu hǎo</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is it good?</span>
* <em>热 不 热</em> ?<span class="pinyin"><em>Rè rè</em>?</span> <span class="trans">Is it hot?</span>
+
* <em>热 不 热</em> ?<span class="pinyin"><em>Rè bu rè</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is it hot?</span>
* 他 <em>帅 不 帅</em> ?<span class="pinyin">Tā <em> shuài bù  shuài </em>?</span> <span class="trans">Is he handsome?</span>
+
* 他 <em>帅 不 帅</em> ?<span class="pinyin">Tā <em> shuài bu shuài</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is he handsome?</span>
* 这里 的 咖啡 <em>贵 不 贵</em> ? <span class="pinyin">Zhèlǐ de kāfēi <em>gùi gùi</em>?</span> <span class="trans">Is the coffee expensive here?</span>
+
* 这里 的 咖啡 <em>贵 不 贵</em> ? <span class="pinyin">Zhèlǐ de kāfēi <em>gùi bu gùi</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is the coffee expensive here?</span>
* 中国 菜 <em>辣 不 辣</em> ? <span class="pinyin">Zhōngguó cài <em>là là</em>?</span> <span class="trans">Is Chinese food spicy?</span>
+
* 中国 菜 <em>辣 不 辣</em> ? <span class="pinyin">Zhōngguó cài <em>là bu là</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is Chinese food spicy?</span>
  
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 82: Line 81:
 
These are something like adding tag questions in English, in this case "Are you an adult or not?" If you wanted to translate it very literally, it would be, "Are you or are you not an adult?" In any case, the structure is a very common way to ask questions in Chinese.
 
These are something like adding tag questions in English, in this case "Are you an adult or not?" If you wanted to translate it very literally, it would be, "Are you or are you not an adult?" In any case, the structure is a very common way to ask questions in Chinese.
  
== Two-character verbs or adjectives in positive-negative questions ==
+
== Two-Character Verbs and Adjectives ==
  
All of the verbs used so far have been single-character verbs. Using two-characters verbs in positive-negative questions is slightly trickier. You usually put 不 (bù) after just the first character, then put the entire verb. For example 喜不喜欢 (xǐ xǐhuan) is the usual question form of 喜欢 (xǐhuan). You can repeat the whole two-character verb twice, but it's more common (and more elegant) to insert 不 (bù) after the first character (and the same is generally true of two-character adjectives).   
+
All of the verbs used so far have been single-character verbs. Using two-characters verbs in affirmative-negative questions is slightly trickier. You usually put 不 (bù) after just the first character, then put the entire verb. For example 喜不喜欢 (xǐ bu xǐhuan) is the usual question form of 喜欢 (xǐhuan). You can repeat the whole two-character verb twice, but it's more common (and more elegant) to insert 不 (bù) after the first character (and the same is generally true of two-character adjectives).   
  
 
=== Structure ===
 
=== Structure ===
Line 108: Line 107:
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
  
* 喜欢 <em>不</em> 喜欢 <span class="expl"> (the whole word is repeated)</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Xǐhuan xǐhuan</em>?</span><span class="trans">Do you like it?</span>
+
* <em>喜欢 喜欢</em><span class="expl pdf-simple-expl">whole word repeated</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Xǐhuan bu xǐhuan</em>?</span><span class="trans">Do you like it?</span>
* <em>不</em> 喜欢 <span class="expl"> (only the first character is repeated)</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Xǐ xǐhuan</em>?</span><span class="trans">Do you like it?</span>
+
* <em>喜欢</em><span class="expl pdf-short-expl">only the first character repeated</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Xǐ bu xǐhuan</em>?</span><span class="trans">Do you like it?</span>
  
* 高兴 <em>不</em> 高兴 <span class="expl"> (the whole word is repeated)</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Gāoxìng gāoxìng</em>?</span><span class="trans">Are you happy?</span>
+
* <em>高兴 高兴</em><span class="expl pdf-simple-expl">whole word repeated</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Gāoxìng bu gāoxìng</em>?</span><span class="trans">Are you happy?</span>
* <em>不</em> 高兴 <span class="expl"> (only the first character is repeated)</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Gāo gāoxìng</em>?</span><span class="trans">Are you happy?</span>
+
* <em>高兴</em><span class="expl pdf-short-expl">only the first character repeated</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Gāo bu gāoxìng</em>?</span><span class="trans">Are you happy?</span>
  
* 他 女朋友 <em>漂亮 不 漂亮</em>?<span class="expl"> (the whole word is repeated)</span><span class="pinyin"> Tā nǚpéngyou <em>piàoliang piàoliang</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is his girlfriend pretty?</span>
+
* 他 女朋友 <em>漂亮 不 漂亮</em>?<span class="expl pdf-simple-expl">whole word repeated</span><span class="pinyin"> Tā nǚpéngyou <em>piàoliang bu piàoliang</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is his girlfriend pretty?</span>
* 他 女朋友 <em>漂 不 漂亮</em>?<span class="expl"> (only the first character is repeated)</span><span class="pinyin">Tā nǚpéngyou <em>piào piàoliang</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is his girlfriend pretty?</span>
+
* 他 女朋友 <em>漂 不 漂亮</em>?<span class="expl pdf-short-expl">only the first character repeated</span><span class="pinyin">Tā nǚpéngyou <em>piào bu piàoliang</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is his girlfriend pretty?</span>
  
* 中国 菜 <em>好吃 不 好吃</em>?<span class="expl"> (the whole word is repeated)</span><span class="pinyin">Zhōngguó cài <em>hǎochī hǎochī</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is Chinese food good?</span>
+
* 中国 菜 <em>好吃 不 好吃</em>?<span class="expl pdf-simple-expl">whole word repeated</span><span class="pinyin">Zhōngguó cài <em>hǎochī bu hǎochī</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is Chinese food good?</span>
* 中国 菜 <em>好 不 好吃</em>?<span class="expl"> (only the first character is repeated)</span><span class="pinyin">Zhōngguó cài <em>hǎo hǎochī</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is Chinese food good?</span>
+
* 中国 菜 <em>好 不 好吃</em>?<span class="expl pdf-short-expl">only the first character repeated</span><span class="pinyin">Zhōngguó cài <em>hǎo bu hǎochī</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is Chinese food good?</span>
  
* 那 个 地方 <em> 好玩 不 好玩</em>?<span class="expl"> (the whole word is repeated)</span><span class="pinyin">Nà ge dìfāng <em> hǎowán hǎowán </em>?</span><span class="trans">Is that place fun?</span>
+
* 那 个 地方 <em>好玩 不 好玩</em>?<span class="expl pdf-simple-expl">whole word repeated</span><span class="pinyin">Nàge dìfang <em> hǎowán bu hǎowán</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is that place fun?</span>
* 那 个 地方 <em> 好 不 好玩</em>?<span class="expl"> (only the first character is repeated)</span><span class="pinyin"> Nà ge dìfāng <em> hǎo hǎowán </em>?</span><span class="trans">Is that place fun?</span>
+
* 那 个 地方 <em>好 不 好玩</em>?<span class="expl pdf-short-expl">only the first character repeated</span><span class="pinyin"> Nàge dìfang <em> hǎo bu hǎowán</em>?</span><span class="trans">Is that place fun?</span>
  
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
== 有 in positive-negative questions ==
+
== 有 (yǒu) Is a Special Case ==
  
 
=== Structure ===
 
=== Structure ===
  
Because the verb [[Negation of "you"|有 (yǒu) is negated with 没 (méi)]] and not 不 (bù), the structure for positive-negative questions with 有 (yǒu) is:
+
Because the verb [[Negation of "you" with "mei"|有 (yǒu) is negated with 没 (méi)]] and not 不 (bù), the structure for affirmative-negative questions with 有 (yǒu) is:
  
 
<div class="jiegou">
 
<div class="jiegou">
  
Subj. + 有没有 + Obj.
+
Subj. + 有 没有 + Obj.
  
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 139: Line 138:
 
The possible answers are: "有 (yǒu)" or "没有 (méiyǒu)."  
 
The possible answers are: "有 (yǒu)" or "没有 (méiyǒu)."  
  
The questions could be be asking about current possession ("do you have it or not?"), or to ask about [[Negation of past actions|verbs in the past]] ("did you do it or not?").
+
The questions could be be asking about current possession ("Do you have it or not?"), or to ask about [[Negation of past actions with "meiyou"|verbs in the past]] ("Did you do it or not?").
  
 
=== Examples ===
 
=== Examples ===
Line 145: Line 144:
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
  
* 你哥哥 <em>有 没有</em> 女 朋友?<span class="pinyin">Nǐgēge <em>yǒu méiyǒu</em> nǚpéngyou?</span> <span class="trans">Does your elder brothe have a girlfriend?</span>
+
*你 哥哥 <em>有 没有</em> 女 朋友?<span class="pinyin">Nǐ gēge <em>yǒu méiyǒu</em> nǚpéngyou?</span><span class="trans">Does your older brother have a girlfriend?</span>
* 你们 <em>有 没有</em> 孩子? <span class="pinyin">Nǐmen <em>yǒu méiyǒu</em> háizi?</span> <span class="trans">Do you have children?</span>
+
*你们 <em>有 没有</em> 孩子? <span class="pinyin">Nǐmen <em>yǒu méiyǒu</em> háizi?</span><span class="trans">Do you have children?</span>
* 你 <em>有 没有</em> 见 过 Obama?<span class="pinyin">Nǐ <em>yǒu méiyǒu</em> jiàn  guo Obama?</span> <span class="trans">Have you met Obama?</span>
+
*奶奶 <em>有 没有</em> 坐 过 飞机? <span class="pinyin">Nǎinai <em>yǒu méiyǒu</em> zuò guo fēijī?</span><span class="trans">Has grandma been on a plane?</span>
* 奶奶 <em>有 没有</em> 坐 过 飞机? <span class="pinyin">Nǎinai<em>yǒu méiyǒu</em> zuò guo fēijī?</span> <span class="trans">Has grandma been on a plane?</span>
+
*他 <em>有 没有</em> 上 过 大学?<span class="pinyin">Tā <em>yǒu méiyǒu</em> shàng guo dàxué?</span><span class="trans">Has he been to college?</span>
* 他 <em>有 没有</em> 上 过 大学?<span class="pinyin">Tā <em>yǒu méiyǒu</em> shàng guo dàxué?</span> <span class="trans">Has he been to college?</span>
 
  
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 166: Line 164:
 
=== Books ===
 
=== Books ===
  
* [[Chinese: An Essential Grammar, Second Edition]] (pp. 141-4) [http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0415372615/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&tag=allset-20&linkCode=as2&camp=217145&creative=399369&creativeASIN=0415372615 →buy]
+
{{Source|HSK Standard Course 2|12}}
* [[Integrated Chinese: Level 1, Part 1 (3rd ed)]] (pp. 86, 102-4) [http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0887276385/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&tag=allset-20&linkCode=as2&camp=217145&creative=399369&creativeASIN=0887276385 →buy]
+
{{Source|Chinese: An Essential Grammar, Second Edition|141-4}}
* [[New Practical Chinese Reader 1 (新实用汉语课本1)]] (p. 87) [http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/7561910401/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&tag=allset-20&linkCode=as2&camp=217145&creative=399369&creativeASIN=7561910401 →buy]
+
{{Source|Integrated Chinese: Level 1, Part 1 (3rd ed)|86, 102-4}}
* [[New Practical Chinese Reader 1 (新实用汉语课本1)(2nd ed)]] (pp. 102, 250-1) [http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/7561926235/ref%3das_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&tag=allset-20&linkCode=as2&camp=217145&creative=399373&creativeASIN=7561926235 →buy]
+
{{Source|New Practical Chinese Reader 1 (新实用汉语课本1)|87}}
 +
{{Source|New Practical Chinese Reader 1 (新实用汉语课本1)(2nd ed)|102, 250-1}}
  
 
[[Category:A1 grammar points]]
 
[[Category:A1 grammar points]]
 +
{{HSK|HSK2}}{{2021-HSK|HSK2}}
 
{{Used for|Asking questions}}
 
{{Used for|Asking questions}}
 
{{Used for|Giving alternatives}}
 
{{Used for|Giving alternatives}}
{{Basic Grammar|不|A1|V + 不 + V/Adjective + 不 + Adjective|<em>去 不 去</em>?<em>好 不 好</em>  ?|grammar point|ASGZH7K3}}
+
{{Basic Grammar|不|A1|Verb + 不 + Verb / Adj. + 不 + Adj.|<em>去 不 去</em>?<em>好 不 好</em>  ?|grammar point|ASGZH7K3}}
 
{{Rel char|没}}
 
{{Rel char|没}}
 
{{Rel char|没有}}
 
{{Rel char|没有}}

Latest revision as of 08:55, 21 April 2021

Also known as: 正反问句 (zhèng-fǎn wènjù) and alternative questions.

A common way to form questions in Chinese is to first use a verb in the positive, then repeat the same verb in its negative form, similar to how in English we can say, "Do you have money or not?" or "Have you or have you not been to the park?" This sentence pattern feels a lot more natural in Chinese than those admittedly awkward English equivalents, however.

Verb-Not-Verb

Structure

Verb + 不 + Verb

Examples

  • 是 不 是Shì bu shì?Is it (or not)?
  • 他们 来 不 来Tāmen lái bu lái?Are they going to come or not?
  • 想 不 想 我 ? xiǎng bu xiǎng wǒ?Do you or do you not miss me?
  • 我们 要 去 酒吧, 你 去 不 去Wǒmen yào qù jiǔbā, nǐ qù bu qù?We are going to the bar. Do you want to go?
  • 我 去 买 咖啡 ,你 要 不 要Wǒ qù mǎi kāfēi, nǐ yào bu yào?I'm going to buy coffee. Do you want some?

Note that the question provides the listener with both possible answers: it's either "Verb" or "不 (bù) Verb."

Verb-Not-Verb with an Object

Structure

If you want to add an object after the verb, the general sentence structure is:

Subj. + Verb + 不 + Verb + Obj.

Examples

  • 回 不 回 家? huí bu huíjiā?Are you coming back home or not?
  • 吃 不 吃 鱼? chī bu chī yú?Does she eat fish?
  • 你们 要 不 要 米饭? Nǐmen yào bu yào mǐfàn?Do you want rice?
  • 你爸爸 喝 不 喝 酒? Nǐ bàba ​hē bu hējiǔ?Does your dad drink alcohol or not?
  • 今天 老板 来 不 来 办公室?Jīntiān lǎobǎn lái bu lái bàngōngshì?Is the boss coming to the office today?


Adjective-Not-Adjective

Structure

It can also be done with adjectives (adjectives often behave like verbs in Chinese):

Adj. + 不 + Adj.

Examples

  • 好 不 好Literally, "good or not good?"Hǎo bu hǎo?Is it good?
  • 热 不 热Rè bu rè?Is it hot?
  • 帅 不 帅 shuài bu shuài?Is he handsome?
  • 这里 的 咖啡 贵 不 贵Zhèlǐ de kāfēi gùi bu gùi?Is the coffee expensive here?
  • 中国 菜 辣 不 辣Zhōngguó cài là bu là?Is Chinese food spicy?

Again, the question provides the listener with both possible answers: it's either "Adjective" or "不 (bù) Adjective."

These are something like adding tag questions in English, in this case "Are you an adult or not?" If you wanted to translate it very literally, it would be, "Are you or are you not an adult?" In any case, the structure is a very common way to ask questions in Chinese.

Two-Character Verbs and Adjectives

All of the verbs used so far have been single-character verbs. Using two-characters verbs in affirmative-negative questions is slightly trickier. You usually put 不 (bù) after just the first character, then put the entire verb. For example 喜不喜欢 (xǐ bu xǐhuan) is the usual question form of 喜欢 (xǐhuan). You can repeat the whole two-character verb twice, but it's more common (and more elegant) to insert 不 (bù) after the first character (and the same is generally true of two-character adjectives).

Structure

It can be done with verbs:

[First Character of Verb] + 不 + Verb

It can also be done with adjectives:

[First Character of Adj.] + 不 + Adj.

Examples

  • 喜欢 不 喜欢whole word repeatedXǐhuan bu xǐhuan?Do you like it?
  • 喜 不 喜欢only the first character repeatedXǐ bu xǐhuan?Do you like it?
  • 高兴 不 高兴whole word repeatedGāoxìng bu gāoxìng?Are you happy?
  • 高 不 高兴only the first character repeatedGāo bu gāoxìng?Are you happy?
  • 他 女朋友 漂亮 不 漂亮whole word repeated Tā nǚpéngyou piàoliang bu piàoliang?Is his girlfriend pretty?
  • 他 女朋友 漂 不 漂亮only the first character repeatedTā nǚpéngyou piào bu piàoliang?Is his girlfriend pretty?
  • 中国 菜 好吃 不 好吃whole word repeatedZhōngguó cài hǎochī bu hǎochī?Is Chinese food good?
  • 中国 菜 好 不 好吃only the first character repeatedZhōngguó cài hǎo bu hǎochī?Is Chinese food good?
  • 那 个 地方 好玩 不 好玩whole word repeatedNàge dìfang hǎowán bu hǎowán?Is that place fun?
  • 那 个 地方 好 不 好玩only the first character repeated Nàge dìfang hǎo bu hǎowán?Is that place fun?

有 (yǒu) Is a Special Case

Structure

Because the verb 有 (yǒu) is negated with 没 (méi) and not 不 (bù), the structure for affirmative-negative questions with 有 (yǒu) is:

Subj. + 有 没有 + Obj.

The possible answers are: "有 (yǒu)" or "没有 (méiyǒu)."

The questions could be be asking about current possession ("Do you have it or not?"), or to ask about verbs in the past ("Did you do it or not?").

Examples

  • 你 哥哥 有 没有 女 朋友?Nǐ gēge yǒu méiyǒu nǚpéngyou?Does your older brother have a girlfriend?
  • 你们 有 没有 孩子? Nǐmen yǒu méiyǒu háizi?Do you have children?
  • 奶奶 有 没有 坐 过 飞机? Nǎinai yǒu méiyǒu zuò guo fēijī?Has grandma been on a plane?
  • 有 没有 上 过 大学?yǒu méiyǒu shàng guo dàxué?Has he been to college?

See also

Sources and further reading

Videos

Books