Difference between revisions of "Simple rhetorical questions"

m (Text replacement - "{{HSK|HSK2}}" to "{{HSK|HSK2}}{{2021-HSK|HSK2}}")
 
(6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 44: Line 44:
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 你 看 到 我 的 手机 了 吗?<span class="pinyin">Nǐ kàn dào wǒ de shǒujī le ma? </span><span class="trans">Have you seen my cell phone?</span></li>
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 你 看 到 我 的 手机 了 吗?<span class="pinyin">Nǐ kàn dào wǒ de shǒujī le ma? </span><span class="trans">Have you seen my cell phone?</span></li>
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span><em>不 是</em> 在 桌子 上 吗?<em> </em><span class="pinyin"><em>Bù shì</em> zài zhuōzi shàng ma? </span><span class="trans">Isn't that it on the table?</span></li>
+
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span><em>不 是</em> 在 桌子 上 <em>吗 ?</em><span class="pinyin"><em>Bù shì</em> zài zhuōzi shàng <em>ma? </em></span><span class="trans">Isn't that it on the table?</span></li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 51: Line 51:
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 我们 什么 时候 开会?<span class="pinyin">Wǒmen shénme shíhou kāi huì?</span><span class="trans">When are we having the meeting?</span></li>
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 我们 什么 时候 开会?<span class="pinyin">Wǒmen shénme shíhou kāi huì?</span><span class="trans">When are we having the meeting?</span></li>
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span><em>不 是</em> 已经 告诉 你 了 吗?<em> </em><span class="pinyin"><em>Bù shì</em> yǐjīng gàosu nǐ le ma?</span><span class="trans">Haven't I told you that already?</span></li>
+
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span><em>不 是</em> 已经 告诉 你 了 <em>吗 ?</em><span class="pinyin"><em>Bù shì</em> yǐjīng gàosu nǐ le <em>ma?</em></span><span class="trans">Haven't I told you that already?</span></li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 58: Line 58:
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 今天 放假 了,好 开心。<span class="pinyin">Jīntiān fàngjià le, hǎo kāixīn. </span><span class="trans">We go on vacation today. I'm so happy!</span></li>
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 今天 放假 了,好 开心。<span class="pinyin">Jīntiān fàngjià le, hǎo kāixīn. </span><span class="trans">We go on vacation today. I'm so happy!</span></li>
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span><em>不 是</em> 明天 放假 吗?<em> </em><span class="pinyin"><em>Bù shì</em> míngtiān fàngjià ma?</span><span class="trans">Doesn't vacation start tomorrow?</span></li>
+
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span><em>不 是</em> 明天 放假 <em>吗 ?</em><span class="pinyin"><em>Bù shì</em> míngtiān fàngjià <em>ma?</em></span><span class="trans">Doesn't vacation start tomorrow?</span></li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 65: Line 65:
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 他 又 感冒 了。<span class="pinyin">Tā yòu gǎnmào le. </span><span class="trans">He's caught another cold.</span></li>
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 他 又 感冒 了。<span class="pinyin">Tā yòu gǎnmào le. </span><span class="trans">He's caught another cold.</span></li>
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span> 他 每天 穿得 都 很少,<em>能</em> 不 感冒 吗?<em> </em><span class="pinyin">Tā měi tiān chuān de dōu hěn shǎo, <em>néng</em> bù gǎnmào ma? </span><span class="trans">He never dresses warmly. How could he not catch a cold?</span></li>
+
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span> 他 每天 穿得 都 很少,<em>能</em> 不 感冒 <em>吗 ?</em><span class="pinyin">Tā měi tiān chuān de dōu hěn shǎo, <em>néng</em> bù gǎnmào <em>ma?</em></span><span class="trans">He never dresses warmly. How could he not catch a cold?</span></li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 72: Line 72:
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 今天 我 可能 会 迟到。<span class="pinyin">Jīntiān wǒ kěnéng huì chídào. </span><span class="trans">I might be late today.</span></li>
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 今天 我 可能 会 迟到。<span class="pinyin">Jīntiān wǒ kěnéng huì chídào. </span><span class="trans">I might be late today.</span></li>
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span>你 起得 这么 晚,<em>能</em> 不 迟到 吗?<em> </em><span class="pinyin">Nǐ qǐ de zhème wǎn, <em>néng</em> bù chídào ma? </span><span class="trans">You got up so late, how could you not be late?</span></li>
+
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span>你 起得 这么 晚,<em>能</em> 不 迟到 <em>吗 ?</em><span class="pinyin">Nǐ qǐ de zhème wǎn, <em>néng</em> bù chídào <em>ma?</em></span><span class="trans">You got up so late, how could you not be late?</span></li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 79: Line 79:
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 我 点 了 很多 菜,都是 你 爱 吃 的。<span class="pinyin">Wǒ diǎn le hěn duō cài, dōu shì nǐ ài chī de. </span><span class="trans">I ordered a bunch of food, all stuff that you like.</span></li>
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 我 点 了 很多 菜,都是 你 爱 吃 的。<span class="pinyin">Wǒ diǎn le hěn duō cài, dōu shì nǐ ài chī de. </span><span class="trans">I ordered a bunch of food, all stuff that you like.</span></li>
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span>晚上 吃 这么 多 菜,<em>能</em> 不 胖 吗?<em> </em><span class="pinyin">Wǎnshang chī zhème duō cài, <em>néng</em> bù pàng ma?</span><span class="trans">Eating so much food at night, how could I not gain weight?</span></li>
+
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span>晚上 吃 这么 多 菜,<em>能</em> 不 胖 <em>吗 ?</em><span class="pinyin">Wǎnshang chī zhème duō cài, <em>néng</em> bù pàng <em>ma?</em></span><span class="trans">Eating so much food at night, how could I not gain weight?</span></li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 93: Line 93:
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 我 收到 了 你 的 邮件。<span class="pinyin">Wǒ shōudào le nǐ de yóujiàn.</span><span class="trans">I received your text.</span></li>
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span> 我 收到 了 你 的 邮件。<span class="pinyin">Wǒ shōudào le nǐ de yóujiàn.</span><span class="trans">I received your text.</span></li>
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span>那 你 <em>怎么 会</em> 不 知道 ?<span class="pinyin">Nà nǐ <em>zěnme huì</em> bù zhīdao?</span><span class="trans">Then how is it that you don't know?</span></li>
+
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span>那 你 <em>怎么 会</em> 不 知道 ?<span class="pinyin">Nà nǐ <em>zěnme huì</em> bù zhīdào?</span><span class="trans">Then how is it that you don't know?</span></li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 100: Line 100:
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span>我 感觉 最近 有 一点 胖 了。<span class="pinyin">Wǒ gǎnjué zuìjìn yǒu yīdiǎn pàng le.</span><span class="trans">I feel like I've gained some weight recently.</span></li>
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span>我 感觉 最近 有 一点 胖 了。<span class="pinyin">Wǒ gǎnjué zuìjìn yǒu yīdiǎn pàng le.</span><span class="trans">I feel like I've gained some weight recently.</span></li>
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span><em>谁 让 你</em> 吃 这么 多。<span class="pinyin"><em>Shéi ràng nǐ</em> chī zhème duō. </span><span class="trans">Who made you eat so much?</span></li>
+
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span><em>谁 让 你</em> 吃 这么 多 ?<span class="expl">Yes, this is totally mean in Chinese too, but people do say stuff like this.</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Shéi ràng nǐ</em> chī zhème duō?</span><span class="trans">Who made you eat so much?</span></li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 107: Line 107:
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<ul class="dialog">
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span>我 找 不到 我 的 钥匙 了。<span class="pinyin">Wǒ zhǎo bùdào wǒ de yàoshi le.</span><span class="trans">I can't find my key.</span></li>
 
<li><span class="speaker">A:</span>我 找 不到 我 的 钥匙 了。<span class="pinyin">Wǒ zhǎo bùdào wǒ de yàoshi le.</span><span class="trans">I can't find my key.</span></li>
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span><em>谁 让 你</em> 不 放 在 包 里。<span class="pinyin"><em>Shéi ràng nǐ </em>bù fàng zài bāo lǐ.</span><span class="trans">What stopped you from putting it in your bag?</span></li>
+
<li><span class="speaker">B:</span><em>谁 让 你</em> 不 放 在 包 里。<span class="expl">Technically a question, but Chinese people often won't write the question mark on a sentence like this.</span><span class="pinyin"><em>Shéi ràng nǐ </em>bù fàng zài bāo lǐ.</span><span class="trans">What stopped you from putting it in your bag?</span></li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
Line 125: Line 125:
  
 
[[Category:B1 grammar points]]
 
[[Category:B1 grammar points]]
{{HSK|HSK2}}
+
{{HSK|HSK2}}{{2021-HSK|HSK2}}
  
 
{{Basic Grammar|吗|B1|不 是…… 吗 ?|不 是 说好 了 吗 ?怎么 会 这样 ?|grammar point|ASGD4EC8}}
 
{{Basic Grammar|吗|B1|不 是…… 吗 ?|不 是 说好 了 吗 ?怎么 会 这样 ?|grammar point|ASGD4EC8}}
Line 135: Line 135:
 
{{Similar|Yes-no questions with "ma"}}
 
{{Similar|Yes-no questions with "ma"}}
 
{{Similar|Rhetorical questions with "nandao"}}
 
{{Similar|Rhetorical questions with "nandao"}}
 +
{{Similar|Advanced uses of "hai"}}
 
{{Used for|Asking questions}}
 
{{Used for|Asking questions}}
 +
{{Used for|Asking rhetorical questions}}
 
{{Used for|Expressing attitude}}
 
{{Used for|Expressing attitude}}
 
{{Translation|who}}
 
{{Translation|who}}

Latest revision as of 08:57, 21 April 2021

Rhetorical questions are ones where the speaker doesn't really expect an answer. The answer should be obvious, and the question is asked in order to make a point.

Structure

There are several very common types of rhetorical questions using basic words you already know:

不是……吗?

This first one is the easiest and most common. It can be quite friendly, seemingly reminding the other person of a fact they seem to have (conveniently?) forgotten.

能……吗?

This one is often quite sarcastic, pointing out someone else's unrealistic expectations. (The obvious answer is "no" here.)

怎么会……?

This second one has a tone of incredulity. The speaker clearly thinks this shouldn't have happened, or thought it couldn't have happened.

谁让你……?

The third one is exclusively used by surly or annoyed people. It means "who told you to...?" or "who made you...?"

Examples

  • A: 你 看 到 我 的 手机 了 吗?Nǐ kàn dào wǒ de shǒujī le ma? Have you seen my cell phone?
  • B:不 是 在 桌子 上 吗 ?Bù shì zài zhuōzi shàng ma? Isn't that it on the table?
  • A: 我们 什么 时候 开会?Wǒmen shénme shíhou kāi huì?When are we having the meeting?
  • B:不 是 已经 告诉 你 了 吗 ?Bù shì yǐjīng gàosu nǐ le ma?Haven't I told you that already?
  • A: 今天 放假 了,好 开心。Jīntiān fàngjià le, hǎo kāixīn. We go on vacation today. I'm so happy!
  • B:不 是 明天 放假 吗 ?Bù shì míngtiān fàngjià ma?Doesn't vacation start tomorrow?
  • A: 他 又 感冒 了。Tā yòu gǎnmào le. He's caught another cold.
  • B: 他 每天 穿得 都 很少, 不 感冒 吗 ?Tā měi tiān chuān de dōu hěn shǎo, néng bù gǎnmào ma?He never dresses warmly. How could he not catch a cold?
  • A: 今天 我 可能 会 迟到。Jīntiān wǒ kěnéng huì chídào. I might be late today.
  • B:你 起得 这么 晚, 不 迟到 吗 ?Nǐ qǐ de zhème wǎn, néng bù chídào ma?You got up so late, how could you not be late?
  • A: 我 点 了 很多 菜,都是 你 爱 吃 的。Wǒ diǎn le hěn duō cài, dōu shì nǐ ài chī de. I ordered a bunch of food, all stuff that you like.
  • B:晚上 吃 这么 多 菜, 不 胖 吗 ?Wǎnshang chī zhème duō cài, néng bù pàng ma?Eating so much food at night, how could I not gain weight?
  • A: 他们 公司 很 厉害。Tāmen gōngsī hěn lìhai. Their company is really impressive.
  • B:但是 他们 公司 怎么 会 有 这么 笨 的 员工?Dànshì tāmen gōngsī zěnme huì yǒu zhème bèn de yuángōng?But then how can they have such a stupid employee?
  • A: 我 收到 了 你 的 邮件。Wǒ shōudào le nǐ de yóujiàn.I received your text.
  • B:那 你 怎么 会 不 知道 ?Nà nǐ zěnme huì bù zhīdào?Then how is it that you don't know?
  • A:我 感觉 最近 有 一点 胖 了。Wǒ gǎnjué zuìjìn yǒu yīdiǎn pàng le.I feel like I've gained some weight recently.
  • B:谁 让 你 吃 这么 多 ?Yes, this is totally mean in Chinese too, but people do say stuff like this.Shéi ràng nǐ chī zhème duō?Who made you eat so much?
  • A:我 找 不到 我 的 钥匙 了。Wǒ zhǎo bùdào wǒ de yàoshi le.I can't find my key.
  • B:谁 让 你 不 放 在 包 里。Technically a question, but Chinese people often won't write the question mark on a sentence like this.Shéi ràng nǐ bù fàng zài bāo lǐ.What stopped you from putting it in your bag?

See also

Sources and further reading

Books

Websites