Difference between revisions of "Expressing ability or possibility with "neng""
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
| − | In English, if we say "I can't speak English" this can have two meanings | + | In English, if we say "I can't speak English" this can have two meanings; I may have been forbidden from speaking English, or it could mean I'm physically unable to speak English. If 能 is used to mean "can" in this sentence, it can only mean the former. This has the potential to create a lot of problems for an English speaker of Chinese. |
Some examples: | Some examples: | ||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
<div class="liju"> | <div class="liju"> | ||
| + | * 我 不 能 说 英文。<span class="expl"> (my teacher has forbidden me from speaking English)</span> | ||
* 我 不 <em>能</em> 游泳。<span class="expl">(the speaker is ill)</span> | * 我 不 <em>能</em> 游泳。<span class="expl">(the speaker is ill)</span> | ||
* 我 <em>能</em> 买 吗？<span class="expl">(the speaker is afraid his girlfriend won't agree) </span> | * 我 <em>能</em> 买 吗？<span class="expl">(the speaker is afraid his girlfriend won't agree) </span> | ||
* 飞机 不 <em>能</em> 起飞。<span class="expl">(it is foggy at the airport)</span> | * 飞机 不 <em>能</em> 起飞。<span class="expl">(it is foggy at the airport)</span> | ||
| − | |||
</div> | </div> | ||
| − | From these examples we can see that 能 is used when there are external obstacles like the weather, obtaining someone's consent | + | From these examples we can see that 能 is used when there are ''external obstacles'' like the weather, obtaining someone's consent or the speaker's health which may prevent the speaker from completing the action in question. In this sense, 能 is similar to 可以. 会 can be used instead if the speaker wishes to express an acquired skill. |
| − | Because 能 can express possibility, it is often used to | + | Because 能 can express possibility, it is often used to form polite questions, something like "would it be possible" in English: |
<div class="liju"> | <div class="liju"> | ||
| + | * 你 <em>能</em> 帮 我 吗? | ||
* 你 <em>能</em> 不 能 给 我 那 本书？ | * 你 <em>能</em> 不 能 给 我 那 本书？ | ||
| − | * | + | * 我 <em>能</em> 问 你 一 个 问题 吗？ |
| − | |||
</div> | </div> | ||
Revision as of 07:17, 22 November 2011
The verb 能 is used to express either ability or possibility. The structure is:
Subject + 能 + Verb + Object
In English, if we say "I can't speak English" this can have two meanings; I may have been forbidden from speaking English, or it could mean I'm physically unable to speak English. If 能 is used to mean "can" in this sentence, it can only mean the former. This has the potential to create a lot of problems for an English speaker of Chinese.
Some examples:
- 我 不 能 说 英文。 (my teacher has forbidden me from speaking English)
- 我 不 能 游泳。(the speaker is ill)
- 我 能 买 吗？(the speaker is afraid his girlfriend won't agree)
- 飞机 不 能 起飞。(it is foggy at the airport)
From these examples we can see that 能 is used when there are external obstacles like the weather, obtaining someone's consent or the speaker's health which may prevent the speaker from completing the action in question. In this sense, 能 is similar to 可以. 会 can be used instead if the speaker wishes to express an acquired skill.
Because 能 can express possibility, it is often used to form polite questions, something like "would it be possible" in English:
- 你 能 帮 我 吗?
- 你 能 不 能 给 我 那 本书？
- 我 能 问 你 一 个 问题 吗？
See also
Sources and further reading
- Sinosplice: Chinese Modal Verb Venn Diagram
