Difference between revisions of "Bu and mei(you)"

m (Text replacement - "<span class="expl"> (" to "<span class="expl">")
 
(14 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Bu and mei(you) can both be used to negate verbs, however they are used differently. Let's first look at how they are used for statements in the past and present.  
+
Although 不 (bù) and (有) (méi(yǒu)) both have the same functions of negating verbs and adjectives, they are used differently. Let's take a look at some of these differences.  
  
 +
==有 is negated with 没==
  
==Past and present statements==
+
没 (rather than 不) is always used to negate 有, the verb meaning "to have."  The phrase "不有" exists only in non-standard Chinese dialects, in obscure set phrases (that you don't need), and in incorrect Chinese.  Keep in mind also that when 没 is used to negate 有, 有 can be dropped altogether.
  
Perhaps the most intuitive explanation of the difference between 不 and 没(有)is that 不 negates actions in the present whereas 没 negates actions in the past.
 
For example:
 
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
* 我 <em></em> <span class="expl"> (I'm not going)</span>
+
 
* 他 <em></em> <span class="expl"> (I didn't go)</span>
+
<ul>
* 我 <em></em> 告诉 他! <span class="expl"> (Honestly, I didn't tell him)</span>
+
<li class="o">没有</li>
* 我 <em></em> 告诉 你  <span class="expl"> (I'm not telling you)</span>
+
<li class="x"><strong>不</strong> 有</li>
 +
<li class="o">我 没有 钱。</li>
 +
<li class="o">我 没 钱。</li>
 +
<li class="x">我 <strong>不</strong> 有 钱。</li>
 +
<li class="o">她 没有 朋友。</li>
 +
<li class="o">她 没 朋友。</li>
 +
<li class="x">她 <strong>不</strong> 有 朋友。</li>
 +
</ul>
 +
 
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
At first this is a good way to remember the difference between the two, but this explanation doesn't neatly cover all uses.
+
==Past and present statements==
  
==Personal and factual statements==
+
Perhaps the most important difference between 不 and 没(有) is that 不 negates actions and statements about the present whereas 没 negates actions and statements about the past.  Note that 没(有) is used to say that something ''has not taken place'', whereas 不 is used to say that something ''is not'' the case, or ''will not happen''.
  
A slightly less intuitive but more encompassing explanation is that 不 is used to negate statements which are based on personal circumstances, whereas 没 is used to negate statements of fact.
+
For example:
 
 
For example:  
 
  
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
* 我 <em></em> <span class="expl"> (I didn't go – an objective statement not reliant on personal views, it is a historical fact)</span>
+
* 我 <em></em> 去。 <span class="expl">I won't go; I'm not going)</span>
* 我 <em></em> <span class="expl"> (I won't go – a decision based on personal circumstances. I won’t go because I don't have the money, because I'm busy or so on. This decision is up to me)</span>
+
* 我 <em></em> 去。 <span class="expl">I didn't go)</span>
* 我 今天<em>没</em> 吃饭 <span class="expl"> (I haven't eaten today. This is a factual statement)</span>
+
* 我 <em>没</em> 告诉 他! <span class="expl">I didn't tell him)</span>
* 我 今天<em>不</em> 吃饭 <span class="expl"> (I'm not eating today. This is an opinion based on personal reasons; perhaps the speaker is feeling ill, is too busy or is too lazy. Again, this is my decision) </span>
+
* 我 <em>不</em> 告诉 你!  <span class="expl">I won't tell you; I'm not telling you)</span>
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
With this clear, it is now easier to explain another two uses of 不 and 没有
+
==A few exceptions==
  
First, is always used to negate 有. 有 means to be exist; when we state that things exist in everyday life, it is a factual statement (for example, "饼干没有了" "there are no biscuits" is a fact . For this reason we cannot negate 有 with 不.
+
The verb 是 is never negated with 没; it can only be negated with 不.
  
Second, statements with negating adjectives are generally personal statementst, therefore we do not use 没 to negate adjectives. We can only say "不好" or "不漂亮", not "没好" or "没漂亮".
+
<div class="liju">
  
 +
<ul>
 +
<li class="o"><em>不</em> 是</li>
 +
<li class="x"><strong>没</strong> 是</li>
 +
<li class="o">昨天 <em>不</em> 是 星期一。</li>
 +
<li class="x">昨天 <strong>没</strong> 是 星期一。</li>
 +
<li class="o">那个 时候,我们 <em>不</em> 是 朋友。</li>
 +
<li class="x">那个 时候,我们 <strong>没</strong> 是 朋友。</li>
 +
</ul>
  
 
The examples below are a little more difficult, as these statement are very similar. However the same rule applies:
 
 
<div class="liju">
 
* 水 <em>没</em> 凉 <span class="expl">(the water hasn't cooled down yet – this emphasizes that the objective process of water cooling hasn't finished yet, as it hasn't yet reached room temperature)</span>
 
* 水<em>不</em> 凉 <span class="expl">(the water isn't cool – here the speaker is making statement based on their belief of what cool is. I might think this water is cool, but you may not, the standard we use is subjective)</span>
 
* 我 <em>不</em> 是 这个 意思 <span class="expl">(No, you've got me wrong, you've judged the situation wrongly - a personal judgement on my behalf that the listener has misjudged me)</span>
 
* 我 <em>没有</em> 这个 意思 <span class="expl">(I never implied that - an objective fact)</span>
 
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
  
 
== Sources and further reading ==
 
== Sources and further reading ==
Line 50: Line 54:
 
=== Websites ===
 
=== Websites ===
  
http://www.docin.com/p-20925643.html
+
* http://www.docin.com/p-20925643.html
http://wenku.baidu.com/view/e2e8eb2ce2bd960590c67703.html
+
* http://wenku.baidu.com/view/e2e8eb2ce2bd960590c67703.html

Latest revision as of 14:33, 17 February 2016

Although 不 (bù) and 没(有) (méi(yǒu)) both have the same functions of negating verbs and adjectives, they are used differently. Let's take a look at some of these differences.

有 is negated with 没

没 (rather than 不) is always used to negate 有, the verb meaning "to have." The phrase "不有" exists only in non-standard Chinese dialects, in obscure set phrases (that you don't need), and in incorrect Chinese. Keep in mind also that when 没 is used to negate 有, 有 can be dropped altogether.

  • 没有
  • 我 没有 钱。
  • 我 没 钱。
  • 有 钱。
  • 她 没有 朋友。
  • 她 没 朋友。
  • 有 朋友。

Past and present statements

Perhaps the most important difference between 不 and 没(有) is that 不 negates actions and statements about the present whereas 没 negates actions and statements about the past. Note that 没(有) is used to say that something has not taken place, whereas 不 is used to say that something is not the case, or will not happen.

For example:

  • 去。 I won't go; I'm not going)
  • 去。 I didn't go)
  • 告诉 他! I didn't tell him)
  • 告诉 你! I won't tell you; I'm not telling you)

A few exceptions

The verb 是 is never negated with 没; it can only be negated with 不.

  • 昨天 是 星期一。
  • 昨天 是 星期一。
  • 那个 时候,我们 是 朋友。
  • 那个 时候,我们 是 朋友。

Sources and further reading

Websites