Difference between revisions of "Comparing "gei" and "wei""

Line 69: Line 69:
 
<tr><td>做</td><td>YES</td><td>YES</td></tr>
 
<tr><td>做</td><td>YES</td><td>YES</td></tr>
 
</table>
 
</table>
 +
 +
{| class="wikitable" style="width:40em"
 +
|+Direction and Potential Complements
 +
|-
 +
! Verb !! Pairs with 给? !! Pairs with 为?
 +
|-
 +
|  发邮件 || YES || no
 +
|-
 +
|  打电话 || YES || no
 +
|-
 +
|  做菜 || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|  做 || YES || YES
 +
|-
 +
|  服务 || no || YES
 +
|-
 +
|  牺牲 || no || YES
 +
|-
 +
|  工作 || no || YES
 +
|-
 +
|}
  
 
== See also ==
 
== See also ==

Revision as of 09:31, 15 December 2020

Both 给 and 为 can mean "for." They seem to be arbitrarily assigned to different verbs, and to make matters worse, some verbs (but not all!) can use either one. There are a few principles you can use to keep them straight, but also a few exceptions you need to memorize. As always, lots of examples help!

The Core Meaning of 给

As you know, 给 is also a verb meaning "to give." As such, 给 is often used with verbs to express an action done out of kindness or friendship. Think of all the things a mother does for a child, or a generous friend does for her bestie. These would use 给.

Structure

Subj. + 给 + Recipient + [Verb Phrase]

Examples

  • 一双 筷子。 Qǐng gěi yī shuāng kuàizi.Please get me a pair of chopsticks.
  • 下 飞机 以后,我 电话。 Xià fēijī yǐhòu, wǒ gěi diànhuà.After getting off the plane, I'll give you a call.
  • 你 别 忘 了 邮件。 Nǐ bié wàng le gěihuí yóujiàn.Don't forget to reply to my email.
  • 同事 介绍 了 公司 的 情况。 Tóngshì gěijièshào le gōngsī de qíngkuàng.My coworker explained the company's situation to me.
  • 这 件 事 是 你 做 得 不 对, 道歉Zhè jiàn shì shì nǐ zuò de bù duì, gěidàoqiàn.What you did was wrong. Apologize to him.
  • 老板 了 很 多 建议。 Lǎobǎn gěi le hěn duō jiànyì.The boss gave me a lot of suggestions.
  • 上海 留下 了 很 深 的 印象。 Shànghǎi gěiliúxià le hěn shēn de yìnxiàng.Shanghai left a deep impression on me.

The Core Meaning of 为

The word 为 automatically feels more formal than 给, due to its association with classical Chinese. Besides being more formal, it is also often associated with obligatory actions or responsibilities. The typical example of this is "to work for Company A": 为A公司工作.

One other common usage of 为 is for uncontrollable emotional reactions that result from relationships with other people. These reactions aren't really done out of kindness; they're spontaneous and not a result of a conscious choice.

Structure

为 + Person + Verb / Adj.

Examples

  • 我 现在 谷歌 公司 工作Wǒ xiànzài wèi Gǔgē gōngsī gōngzuò.I currently work for Google.
  • 国家 过 贡献 吗 ? wèi guójiā zuò guò gòngxiàn ma?Have you made a contribution to our country?
  • 我 真的 高兴Wǒ zhēnde wèigāoxìng.I'm truly happy for you.
  • 父母 孩子 付出 了 很 多。 Fùmǔ wèi háizi fùchū le hěn duō.The parents did a lot for their child.
  • 父母 管 孩子 总是 说 是 孩子 Fùmǔ guǎn háizi zǒngshì shuō shì wèi háizi hǎo.When parents micro-manage their kids, they always say it's for their children's own good.
  • 我们 都 是 成年人 了,应该 自己 的 行为 负责Wǒmen dōu shì chéngniánrén le, yīnggāi wèi zìjǐ de xíngwéi fùzé.We've all adults now, and ought to be responsible for our own actions.
  • 政府 公司 提供 了 保障。 Zhèngfǔ wèi gōngsī tígōng le bǎozhàng.The government provides companies certain protections.

Comparison of 给 and 为 by Collocation

What could be more helpful than a big long list of examples? We've done our best to include the most common words that pair (collocate) with 给 and 为, but this list is, of course, not exhaustive.

Verb Pairs with 给? Pairs with 为?
发邮件YESno
打电话YESno
做菜YESYES
服务noYES
牺牲noYES
贡献noYES
工作noYES
YESYES
Direction and Potential Complements
Verb Pairs with 给? Pairs with 为?
发邮件 YES no
打电话 YES no
做菜 YES YES
YES YES
服务 no YES
牺牲 no YES
工作 no YES

See also

Sources and further reading

Books

HSK5