Difference between revisions of "Expressing comparable degree with "you""

(→‎Examples: The food you cooked is as delicious as I cooked? → Is the food you cooked as delicious as the one I cooked?)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{Grammar Box}}  
 
{{Grammar Box}}  
  
有(yǒu), besides just meaning "to have", can also be used in comparisons. In English, we can sometimes say "She has her mother's cuteness" or "I have my father's height", though they sound a bit awkward. In Chinese, however, it's pretty common. You can use 有 to express degree in a simple statement, though it is usually used in a question.
+
有 (yǒu), besides just meaning "to have," can also be used in comparisons. It's what you use instead of 比 (bǐ) if something is "as [adjective] as" something else.
 
 
One important thing to note is that this 有 has the meaning of expressing a certain nature, characteristic, number or degree. Therefore, it's important to remember to use this grammar pattern with those types of adjectives!
 
  
 
== Basic structure ==
 
== Basic structure ==
  
The structure is very straightforward. It simply means "A has B's (adjective)." The meaning is like saying "A is the same (adjective) as B."
+
The structure is very straightforward. It literally means "A has B's [adjective]." The meaning is "A is as [adjective] as B."
  
 
<div class="jiegou">
 
<div class="jiegou">
  
A 有 B + Adjective + 吗?
+
A 有 B + Adjective
  
 
</div>
 
</div>
 +
 +
This pattern is often used in questions.
  
 
=== Examples ===
 
=== Examples ===
Line 22: Line 22:
 
* 红酒 <em>有</em> 白酒 好喝 吗?<span class="trans">Is red wine as tasty to drink as white wine?</span>
 
* 红酒 <em>有</em> 白酒 好喝 吗?<span class="trans">Is red wine as tasty to drink as white wine?</span>
 
* 你 的 儿子 <em>有</em> 我 的 调皮 吗?<span class="trans">Is your son as naughty as mine?</span>
 
* 你 的 儿子 <em>有</em> 我 的 调皮 吗?<span class="trans">Is your son as naughty as mine?</span>
* 你 的 中文 <em>有</em> John 好 吗?<span class="trans">Is your Chinese as good as John's?</span>
+
* 你 的 中文 <em>有</em> 大山 好 吗?<span class="trans">Is your Chinese as good as Dashan's?</span>
 
* 上海 的 房子 <em>有</em> 纽约 的 贵 吗?<span class="trans">Are the apartments in Shanghai as expensive as the ones in New York?</span>
 
* 上海 的 房子 <em>有</em> 纽约 的 贵 吗?<span class="trans">Are the apartments in Shanghai as expensive as the ones in New York?</span>
* 你 做 的 饭 <em>有</em> 我 做 的 好吃 吗?<span class="trans">Is the food you cooked as delicious as the one I cooked?</span>
+
* 你 做 的 饭 <em>有</em> 我 做 的 好吃 吗?<span class="trans">Is the food you cooked as delicious as what I cooked?</span>
 
* 你 的 衣服 <em>有</em> 我 的 多 吗?<span class="trans">Do you have as many clothes as I do?</span>
 
* 你 的 衣服 <em>有</em> 我 的 多 吗?<span class="trans">Do you have as many clothes as I do?</span>
 
* 泰国 <em>有</em> 巴厘岛 好玩 吗?<span class="trans">Is Thailand as fun as Bali?</span>
 
* 泰国 <em>有</em> 巴厘岛 好玩 吗?<span class="trans">Is Thailand as fun as Bali?</span>
Line 38: Line 38:
 
== Structure with 那么 ==
 
== Structure with 那么 ==
  
This form is often used with 那么, which in this case means "as much". This is sort of like saying "You are as much tall as your brother", though that sentence is not very standard (and possibly grammatically incorrect).
+
This form is often used with 那么, which in this case means "as much." This is sort of like saying "You are as much tall as your brother," but it actually sounds good in Chinese.
  
 
<div class="jiegou">
 
<div class="jiegou">
Line 56: Line 56:
 
* 上海 的 房子 <em>有</em> 纽约 的 那么 贵 吗?<span class="trans">Are the apartments in Shanghai just as expensive as in New York?</span>
 
* 上海 的 房子 <em>有</em> 纽约 的 那么 贵 吗?<span class="trans">Are the apartments in Shanghai just as expensive as in New York?</span>
 
* 你 做 的 饭 <em>有</em> 我 做 的 那么 好吃 吗?<span class="trans">Is your cooked food just as good as mine?</span>
 
* 你 做 的 饭 <em>有</em> 我 做 的 那么 好吃 吗?<span class="trans">Is your cooked food just as good as mine?</span>
* 你 的 衣服 <em>有</em> 我 的 那么 多 吗?<span class="trans">Do you have as much clothes as I do?</span>
+
* 你 的 衣服 <em>有</em> 我 的 那么 多 吗?<span class="trans">Do you have as many clothes as I do?</span>
 
* 泰国 <em>有</em> 巴厘岛 那么 好玩 吗?<span class="trans">Is Thailand just as fun as Bali?</span>
 
* 泰国 <em>有</em> 巴厘岛 那么 好玩 吗?<span class="trans">Is Thailand just as fun as Bali?</span>
* 伦敦 的 人口 <em>有</em> 上海 那么 多 吗?<span class="trans">Is London's population as much as Shanghai's?</span>
+
* 伦敦 的 人口 <em>有</em> 上海 那么 多 吗?<span class="trans">Is London's population as big as Shanghai's?</span>
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
  
Make sure that you use an adjective with this form. In English we may say something like "You have your mother's eyes", but you cannot say that in Chinese.
+
Make sure that you use an ''adjective'' with this form. In English we may say something like "You have your mother's eyes," but you cannot say that in Chinese.
  
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">

Revision as of 07:29, 23 September 2014

有 (yǒu), besides just meaning "to have," can also be used in comparisons. It's what you use instead of 比 (bǐ) if something is "as [adjective] as" something else.

Basic structure

The structure is very straightforward. It literally means "A has B's [adjective]." The meaning is "A is as [adjective] as B."

A 有 B + Adjective

This pattern is often used in questions.

Examples

  • 我 帅 吗?Is he as handsome as me?
  • 我 可爱 吗?Is she as cute as me?
  • 红酒 白酒 好喝 吗?Is red wine as tasty to drink as white wine?
  • 你 的 儿子 我 的 调皮 吗?Is your son as naughty as mine?
  • 你 的 中文 大山 好 吗?Is your Chinese as good as Dashan's?
  • 上海 的 房子 纽约 的 贵 吗?Are the apartments in Shanghai as expensive as the ones in New York?
  • 你 做 的 饭 我 做 的 好吃 吗?Is the food you cooked as delicious as what I cooked?
  • 你 的 衣服 我 的 多 吗?Do you have as many clothes as I do?
  • 泰国 巴厘岛 好玩 吗?Is Thailand as fun as Bali?
  • 伦敦 的 人口 上海 多 吗?Is London's population as much as Shanghai's?

Notice that all these example sentences are questions. Typically this form is used in questions, although they can be used in simple statements, like:

  • 我 高。He is as tall as me.

Structure with 那么

This form is often used with 那么, which in this case means "as much." This is sort of like saying "You are as much tall as your brother," but it actually sounds good in Chinese.

A 有 B + 那么 + Adjective + 吗?

Examples

  • 我 那么 帅 吗?Is he as handsome as me?
  • 我 那么 可爱 吗?Is she as cute as me?
  • 红酒 白酒 那么 好喝 吗?Is red wine as good to drink as white wine?
  • 你 的 儿子 我 的 那么 调皮 吗?Is your son as naughty as mine?
  • 你 的 中文 John 那么 好 吗?Is your Chinese as good as John's?
  • 上海 的 房子 纽约 的 那么 贵 吗?Are the apartments in Shanghai just as expensive as in New York?
  • 你 做 的 饭 我 做 的 那么 好吃 吗?Is your cooked food just as good as mine?
  • 你 的 衣服 我 的 那么 多 吗?Do you have as many clothes as I do?
  • 泰国 巴厘岛 那么 好玩 吗?Is Thailand just as fun as Bali?
  • 伦敦 的 人口 上海 那么 多 吗?Is London's population as big as Shanghai's?


Make sure that you use an adjective with this form. In English we may say something like "You have your mother's eyes," but you cannot say that in Chinese.

  • 你 妈妈 的 眼睛。You (literally) have your mother's eyes. (Incorrect)
  • 你 的 眼睛 你 妈妈 的 眼睛 那么 大。Your eyes are as big as your mother's eyes.


The negative form of this grammar pattern is with 没有.

See also

Sources and further reading

Books