Difference between revisions of "Comparing "bu" and "mei""

Line 57: Line 57:
 
== 不 is used to ask questions ==
 
== 不 is used to ask questions ==
  
There a couple ways to use 不 to ask questions. One such way is through positive-negative questions. This is done by stating a verb and then immediately repeating that verb in a negative state (with 不):
+
There a couple ways to use 不 to ask questions. One such way is through [[affirmative-negative question]]s. This is done by stating a verb and then immediately repeating that verb in a negative state (with 不):
  
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
Line 65: Line 65:
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
不 can also be used to form tag questions.  Tag questions use the positive-negative question form, but are placed at the end of the sentence. Tag questions are used to seek approval or acceptance for a statement, very similar to the English "OK?" or "right?"  You can't use 没 for this.
+
不 can also be used to form [[Tag questions with "bu"|tag questions]].  Tag questions use the positive-negative question form, but are placed at the end of the sentence. Tag questions are used to seek approval or acceptance for a statement, very similar to the English "OK?" or "right?"  You can't use 没 for this.
  
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
Line 76: Line 76:
 
</div>  
 
</div>  
  
 +
== 没 is used to negate past actions ==
  
See the grammar page for Positive negative questions here:
+
没 and 没有 can both be used to [[negation of past actions|negate actions that occurred in the past]], or to say that something has not happened yet.
http://resources.allsetlearning.com/chinese/grammar/Positive_negative_questions
 
 
 
See the grammar page for Tag questions here:
 
http://resources.allsetlearning.com/chinese/grammar/Tag_questions_with_%22bu%22
 
 
 
== 不 is used almost exclusively with some verbs ==
 
  
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
 
<ul>
 
<ul>
<li class="o">明天 我 <em></em> 在 家。</li>
+
<li class="o">他 <em>没有</em> 打 电话 给 我。</li>
<li class="x">上周 我 <em>不</em> 和 我 的 朋友 在 一起。</li>
+
<li class="o">他 <em>没有</em> 上课。</li>
 +
<li class="o"><strong>昨天</strong> <em></em> 喝 葡萄酒。</li>
 +
<li class="x">我 <strong>昨天</strong> <em>不</em> 喝 葡萄酒 。</li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
  
== 不: other uses ==
+
There are a few things worth noting in these examples. For one, it is still grammatically correct to leave out the 有 in the sentences using 没有Also, the sentence using 不 ''would be'' grammatically correct, if not for the 昨天 ("yesterday") telling us that it is definitely the '''past''' we're talking about. That incorrect sentence using 不 would translate into *"I don't drink wine yesterday" as opposed to "I ''didn't'' drink wine yesterday."
不 is a very common word in the Chinese language and an integral part of many grammar points.  See those grammar points here:
 
http://resources.allsetlearning.com/chinese/grammar/%E4%B8%8D
 
 
 
== 没: general use ==
 
 
 
“没”用于描述过去,说明动作没有发生。很多时候和“有”一起用,意思和用法不变。
 
is used to describe actions in the past or illustrate that an action hasn’t happened yet.   
 
 
 
===Structure===
 
 
 
<div class="jiegou">
 
Subject + 没(有)+ V.
 
</div>
 
 
 
===Examples===
 
 
 
<div class="liju">
 
*昨天 晚上 我 <em>没</em> 吃 饭。
 
*他 <em>没有</em> 去 公园。
 
</div>
 
 
 
<div class="liju">
 
<ul>
 
<li class="x">明天 我 <em>没</em> 在 家。</li>
 
<li class="o">上周 我 <em>没</em> 和 我 的 朋友 在 一起。</li>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
 
 
See the grammar page here:
 
http://resources.allsetlearning.com/chinese/grammar/Standard_negation_with_%22bu%22
 
  
 
==Only 没 is used to negate 有 ==
 
==Only 没 is used to negate 有 ==
Line 161: Line 128:
 
You can only use 没 or 没有 for this purpose, and '''not''' 不.
 
You can only use 没 or 没有 for this purpose, and '''not''' 不.
  
== is used to negate past actions ==
+
== is used almost exclusively with some verbs ==
  
没 and 没有 can both be used to [[negation of past actions|negate actions that occurred in the past]].
+
Certain verbs just don't get negated by or 没有 ever.  These include the verbs 是 ("to be") and 在 ("to be (in a place)"), as well as some psychological verbs such as 知道 ("to know") and 认识 ("to know (a person)").  For these verbs, it's best to just take them on a case-by-case basis.  Being aware of their existence can save you a fair bit of confusion.
  
 
<div class="liju">
 
<div class="liju">
 
<ul>
 
<ul>
<li class="o">他 <em>没有</em> 打 电话 给 我。</li>
+
<li class="o">他 以前 <em></em> 是 我的 朋友 。</li>
<li class="o">他 <em>没有</em> 上课。</li>
+
<li class="x">他 以前 <em></em> 是 我的 朋友 。</li>
<li class="o">我 <strong>昨天</strong> <em></em> 喝 葡萄酒。</li>
+
<li class="o">昨天 我 <em>不</em> 在 家。</li>
<li class="x">我 <strong>昨天</strong> <em>不</em> 喝 葡萄酒 。</li>
+
<li class="x">昨天 我 <em>没</em> 在 家。</li>
 +
<li class="o">昨天 我 <em></em> 知道。</li>
 +
<li class="x">昨天 我 <em>没</em> 知道。</li>
 +
<li class="o">他 以前 <em>不</em> 认识 她 。</li>
 +
<li class="o">他 以前 <em>没</em> 认识 她 。</li>
 
</ul>
 
</ul>
 
</div>
 
</div>
 
There are a few things worth noting in these examples. For one, it is still grammatically correct to leave out the 有 in the sentences using 没有.  Also, the sentence using 不 ''would be'' grammatically correct, if not for the 昨天 ("yesterday") telling us that it is definitely the '''past''' we're talking about. That incorrect sentence using 不 would translate into *"I don't drink wine yesterday" as opposed to "I ''didn't'' drink wine yesterday."
 
  
 
== Sources and further reading ==
 
== Sources and further reading ==

Revision as of 07:44, 26 November 2012

Both 不(bù) and 没 (méi) can be placed in front of a verb or adjective to negate its meaning. However, 不 and 没 are not usually interchangeable, so it's important to learn when you must use 不 as opposed to 没, and vice versa.

不 is for negating in the present and future

不 is generally used to negate an action that you do not want to do or do not intend to do (in the future). So expressing things like "I don't want to go" or "I'm not going" would be uses of 不.

Structure

Subject + 不 + Verb

Examples

Whether it's "don't wanna do it" or "not gonna do it," use 不:

  • 我 今天 晚上 吃 饭。
  • 我 今天 晚上 想 吃 饭。
  • 去 公园。
  • 要 去 公园。

不 is used to negate habitual actions

不 can be used to negate habitual actions, to express what you just aren't in the habit of doing, such as eating meat, or watching TV, or drinking alcohol. This is simply done by placing 不 in front of the verb.

  • 吃 肉。
  • 看 电视。
  • 喝 酒。

Please note that, while it is grammatically correct to use 没 in all the sentences above, 没 does not negate any habitual actions. The sentences above, if they contained 没 instead of 不, would express that the speaker didn't do the named activity (at once particular point in the past). So it would not be about habitual actions.

不 is normally used with adjectives

When it comes to a simple negation of an adjective (e.g. "not Adj"), use 不.

Structure

不 + Adj

Examples

  • 高兴。
  • 漂亮。
  • 你的 女朋友 难看。
  • 我们 饿。
  • 聪明。

不 is used to ask questions

There a couple ways to use 不 to ask questions. One such way is through affirmative-negative questions. This is done by stating a verb and then immediately repeating that verb in a negative state (with 不):

  • 是 不 是 我 的 老师。
  • 今天 你 来 不 来
  • 喜 不 喜欢 吃 中国菜。

不 can also be used to form tag questions. Tag questions use the positive-negative question form, but are placed at the end of the sentence. Tag questions are used to seek approval or acceptance for a statement, very similar to the English "OK?" or "right?" You can't use 没 for this.

  • 我们 去 吃饭,好 不 好
  • 你 是 我的 同学,对 不 对
  • 我们 喝 水,好 没 好
  • 你 得 上 课,对 没 对

没 is used to negate past actions

没 and 没有 can both be used to negate actions that occurred in the past, or to say that something has not happened yet.

  • 没有 打 电话 给 我。
  • 没有 上课。
  • 昨天 喝 葡萄酒。
  • 昨天 喝 葡萄酒 。

There are a few things worth noting in these examples. For one, it is still grammatically correct to leave out the 有 in the sentences using 没有. Also, the sentence using 不 would be grammatically correct, if not for the 昨天 ("yesterday") telling us that it is definitely the past we're talking about. That incorrect sentence using 不 would translate into *"I don't drink wine yesterday" as opposed to "I didn't drink wine yesterday."

Only 没 is used to negate 有

没 can be used to negate the verb 有 ("to have") to mean "do not have." You can only use 没 to convey this meaning. It is grammatically incorrect to use 不 to negate 有.

  • 没有 钱。
  • 不 有 钱。
  • 没有 女朋友。
  • 不 有 女朋友。

There are times when you can leave out 有 entirely while still expressing 没有 (meaning "to not have" or "there is no"). One well-known example of this is 没办法 ("there is no way" [that's gonna happen]). Both 没 and 没有 are correct, however.

  • 办法。
  • 没有 办法。

(You can also use 没办法 to express other meanings.)

没 is used to make comparisons

没 or 没有 can be used to make simple comparisons meaning "not as... as":

  • 我 的 钱 没有 他 的 钱 多。
  • 你 的 钱 不 有 他 的 钱 多。
  • 没有 我 高兴。
  • 不 有 我 高兴。

You can only use 没 or 没有 for this purpose, and not 不.

不 is used almost exclusively with some verbs

Certain verbs just don't get negated by 没 or 没有 ever. These include the verbs 是 ("to be") and 在 ("to be (in a place)"), as well as some psychological verbs such as 知道 ("to know") and 认识 ("to know (a person)"). For these verbs, it's best to just take them on a case-by-case basis. Being aware of their existence can save you a fair bit of confusion.

  • 他 以前 是 我的 朋友 。
  • 他 以前 是 我的 朋友 。
  • 昨天 我 在 家。
  • 昨天 我 在 家。
  • 昨天 我 知道。
  • 昨天 我 知道。
  • 他 以前 认识 她 。
  • 他 以前 认识 她 。

Sources and further reading

Books